Why Scotland and Wales Are Pushing Back Against Andy Burnham Over Local Devolution

Why Scotland and Wales Are Pushing Back Against Andy Burnham Over Local Devolution

The leaders of the Scottish and Welsh governments have drawn a sharp constitutional boundary, informing Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham that decisions regarding local devolution within Scotland and Wales rest exclusively with their respective administrations in Edinburgh and Cardiff. This pushback follows proposals from Burnham—who has increasingly positioned himself as a leading voice for English regional devolution and broader UK constitutional reform—suggesting a coordinated, pan-UK approach to empowering local mayors and regional authorities. For the First Ministers of Scotland and Wales, however, any attempt to standardize or centrally coordinate sub-national governance across the United Kingdom threatens the foundational principles of the 1998 devolution settlements.

At the heart of this dispute is a fundamental disagreement over how power should be distributed across the British Isles. While Burnham advocates for a radical decentralization of power away from Westminster to city-regions across the entire UK, the devolved governments view their constitutional status as fundamentally distinct from English metro mayors. To Edinburgh and Cardiff, local government structure within their borders is not a matter for cross-border mayors or UK-wide frameworks to dictate. It is an internal, devolved competence guaranteed by statute.

The Constitutional Divide Between Devolved Nations and Metro Mayors

To understand why the First Ministers reacted so decisively, one must look at the asymmetric nature of the UK constitution. Devolution in the United Kingdom was never designed as a uniform federal system. Instead, it evolved piecemeal in the late 1990s through specific acts of Parliament—namely the Scotland Act 1998 and the Government of Wales Act 1998—which established national legislatures with broad primary law-making powers.

In contrast, English devolution has taken the form of combined authorities led by directly elected metro mayors, such as Andy Burnham in Greater Manchester or Steve Rotheram in the Liverpool City Region. These roles were created through bespoke devolution deals negotiated with Whitehall, granting mayors specific administrative and budgetary powers over transport, housing, and skills, rather than primary legislative authority.

From the perspective of the Scottish and Welsh governments, equating a national parliament with an English combined authority is a constitutional category error. In both Scotland and Wales, the structure, funding, and powers of local councils are explicitly devolved matters. Neither Westminster nor an English regional mayor holds jurisdiction over how Aberdeen or Swansea is governed. When Burnham speaks of creating a new constitutional settlement that empowers local leaders across the whole of Britain, officials in Edinburgh and Cardiff hear an implicit challenge to their own legislative autonomy.

The Architecture of Devolved Competence

Under the reserved powers model currently operating in both Scotland and Wales, any policy area not explicitly retained by the UK Parliament in Westminster is automatically the responsibility of the Scottish Parliament or Senedd Cymru. Local government falls squarely within this devolved sphere.

  • Council Structures: Edinburgh and Cardiff determine the boundaries, electoral systems, and administrative frameworks of their local authorities. Scotland has 32 unitary councils; Wales has 22.
  • Funding Mechanisms: The block grants distributed by the UK Treasury to the Scottish and Welsh governments are allocated to local councils according to priorities set by Holyrood and the Senedd, not Whitehall.
  • Sub-National Reforms: Whether Scotland or Wales chooses to introduce regional mayors, empower local community boards, or reform council tax is entirely a decision for their own elected representatives.

By asserting that local devolution decisions rest solely with them, the First Ministers are defending the integrity of this legal framework. They argue that any pan-UK initiative aimed at standardizing local governance risks bypassing the democratic mandates of the devolved parliaments.

Andy Burnham's Vision for a Rewired Britain

Andy Burnham's interventions on constitutional reform stem from a well-documented frustration with the hyper-centralization of the British state. Having served as a cabinet minister in Westminster before becoming Mayor of Greater Manchester in 2017, Burnham has frequently argued that the UK suffers from a democratic deficit. In his view, Whitehall hoards too much power and capital, leaving regions outside London and the South East underfunded and overlooked.

Burnham has repeatedly called for what he terms a "rewiring" of the UK. His proposals often include replacing the House of Lords with an elected Senate of the Nations and Regions, enshrining devolution in law so Whitehall cannot arbitrarily claw back powers, and establishing a statutory Council of the Nations and Regions where the UK Prime Minister, the First Ministers of the devolved nations, and English metro mayors sit as equals to coordinate national policy.

It is this last proposal—placing metro mayors on an equal footing with First Ministers within a unified UK governance structure—that generates friction. For Burnham, a Council of the Nations and Regions is a practical mechanism to ensure that northern England has the same voice in Westminster as Scotland or Wales. He points out that Greater Manchester's population of nearly three million is comparable to that of Wales, arguing that economic geography should dictate political representation.

Yet, what looks like equitable representation from Manchester looks like constitutional dilution from Edinburgh and Cardiff.

Why Edinburgh and Cardiff Guard Their Turf

The resistance from the First Ministers is rooted in both constitutional principle and recent political history. Over the past decade, particularly following the UK's exit from the European Union, tensions between Westminster and the devolved administrations have escalated sharply.

Both the Scottish and Welsh governments have accused successive UK governments of undermining the devolution settlement through legislation such as the UK Internal Market Act 2020. That act gave UK ministers the power to spend money directly in devolved areas—such as infrastructure and economic development—bypassing Holyrood and the Senedd entirely. To leaders in Scotland and Wales, this represented a rollback of their hard-won autonomy, effectively treating their nations as mere regions of a unitary state rather than distinct polities within a voluntary union.

Against this backdrop, any proposal that blurs the line between a devolved nation and an English city-region is viewed with deep suspicion.

The Politics of Parity

If a formal UK-wide framework were established to govern local devolution, the First Ministers fear it would erode their status as heads of national governments. In political terms, parity between a First Minister and a metro mayor reduces Scotland and Wales to the level of English counties or combined authorities.

Consider a hypothetical scenario where a UK-wide council sets minimum standards or structural templates for local mayors across Britain. Even if intended to empower local communities, such a mechanism would implicitly subordinate the legislative authority of the Scottish Parliament and the Senedd to a broader UK consensus. For the Scottish National Party (SNP) in Edinburgh, which campaigns for full independence, accepting parity with an English region is politically untenable. Even for Welsh Labour in Cardiff, which favors a federalized UK and shares a party banner with Burnham, preserving the distinct constitutional standing of the Senedd remains an absolute red line.

Furthermore, both nations have already pursued their own distinct paths on local democracy. Wales has implemented significant local government reforms, including extending the voting franchise to 16- and 17-year-olds and allowing councils to adopt different voting systems. Scotland has long utilized the Single Transferable Vote for local elections, resulting in widespread coalition governance at the council level—a stark contrast to the First Past the Post system used for English local elections. Neither administration sees a need to import an English metro-mayor model that was designed to solve England's specific lack of regional representation.

The Unresolved English Question

The friction between Burnham and the First Ministers highlights a structural flaw that has plagued British politics since 1998: the unresolved "English Question." While Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland gained their own legislatures, England—comprising roughly 84 percent of the UK's population—remained governed directly by the UK Parliament.

The creation of metro mayors was an attempt to answer this question without breaking England into artificial administrative regions, an idea voters rejected in the 2004 North East England devolution referendum. Over time, Burnham and his fellow mayors have successfully leveraged their platforms to demand greater fiscal autonomy, control over rail networks, and integrated public transport systems.

However, as English mayors grow more powerful, they inevitably bump up against the existing constitutional architecture of the wider UK. When Burnham advocates for stronger regional voices in national decision-making, he is addressing a genuine imbalance. England's regions do lack the institutional representation enjoyed by the devolved nations.

The problem lies in the mechanism. Attempting to solve England's governance deficit by creating pan-UK structures that encompass Scotland and Wales creates immediate constitutional friction. Experts in British constitutional law have long noted that England's governance must be resolved within England, rather than by retrofitting the devolution settlements of the other three nations to accommodate English mayors.

Internal Pressures Within Scotland and Wales

While the First Ministers are united in telling Burnham to stay out of their jurisdiction, both administrations face their own domestic criticisms regarding centralization. Ironically, many local council leaders in Scotland and Wales complain of the exact same dynamic that Burnham criticizes in Westminster.

In Scotland, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA) has frequently clashed with the Scottish Government over ring-fenced budgets and a perceived hoarding of power in Edinburgh. Critics argue that since the creation of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, power has flowed upward from local councils to Holyrood, rather than downward to communities. Proposals to introduce directly elected mayors in Scottish cities like Glasgow or Edinburgh have occasionally surfaced in policy debates, though they have gained little traction among the major parties.

A similar dynamic exists in Wales. The Welsh Local Government Association has consistently pushed for greater fiscal freedom from Cardiff Bay, arguing that local authorities bear the brunt of austerity while having limited revenue-raising powers. While the Welsh Government has established Corporate Joint Committees to encourage regional collaboration among councils on transport and strategic planning, it has stopped well short of creating executive metro mayors along the Greater Manchester model.

These internal debates demonstrate that local devolution is indeed a live issue in both Scotland and Wales. However, the First Ministers' message to Burnham makes clear that these debates will be settled internally by Scottish and Welsh voters and their elected parliaments.

Navigating Intergovernmental Relations

The dispute also underscores the fragility of intergovernmental relations within the United Kingdom. For years, constitutional experts have criticized the ad-hoc nature of communication between Whitehall, Edinburgh, Cardiff, and Belfast. The Joint Ministerial Committee system, established in 1999 to manage disputes and coordinate policy, was widely regarded as dysfunctional and overly dominated by the UK government.

Subsequent reforms introduced a new three-tier system of intergovernmental councils intended to foster greater collaboration and mutual respect. Yet, integrating English metro mayors into this architecture remains awkward. When mayors are invited to participate in UK-wide forums alongside First Ministers, protocol and constitutional hierarchy quickly become contentious issues.

For UK policymakers, the challenge is finding a way to give English regional leaders a meaningful voice on cross-border issues—such as national infrastructure, energy grids, and economic strategy—without infringing upon the legislative competencies of the devolved administrations.

Burnham's push for a more decentralized Britain has undeniably shifted the political conversation in Westminster, forcing major parties to take regional inequality seriously. Yet his exchange with the First Ministers serves as a reminder that the United Kingdom is not a blank slate. Any blueprint for constitutional reform that fails to respect the hard boundaries of the 1998 devolution settlements will meet immediate resistance from the nations that already govern themselves.

ST

Scarlett Taylor

A former academic turned journalist, Scarlett Taylor brings rigorous analytical thinking to every piece, ensuring depth and accuracy in every word.