Why Jim Cramer Called Celsius a Second Rate Monster and What Investors Need to Know

Jim Cramer rarely holds back during his Mad Money lightning round. When a caller recently asked him about Celsius Holdings, the CNBC host didn't mince words. He brushed the stock aside, flatly calling Celsius a "second rate Monster."

Ouch. If you own shares of CELH, that sting probably lingered.

Cramer's dismissal hits right at the center of one of the fiercest battles in the beverage aisle. For years, retail investors treated Celsius like an unstoppable rocket ship, riding massive revenue growth and a blockbuster distribution deal with PepsiCo. Then the stock hit a wall. Growth cooled off, inventory bottlenecks piled up, and Wall Street started asking hard questions about whether Celsius was actually dethroning the energy drink giants or just having a temporary moment in the sun.

So, is Cramer right? Or is he missing the bigger picture of how modern consumers actually buy caffeine? Let's break down the reality behind the soundbite.

What Prompted Jim Cramer's Celsius Criticism

To understand Cramer's blunt assessment, you have to look at the timeline of Celsius Holdings over the past few years. Between 2021 and early 2024, Celsius was the darling of growth investors. The company carved out a massive niche by marketing itself as a "better-for-you" functional energy drink—zero sugar, no artificial preservatives, and loaded with vitamins and green tea extract. It appealed to gym-goers, suburban parents, and college students who wouldn't touch a traditional neon-colored energy drink with a ten-foot pole.

Wall Street loved it. The stock surged, splitting 3-for-1 in late 2023 as quarterly revenue routinely doubled year-over-year.

Then came the hangover.

During the second half of 2024 and into 2025, PepsiCo—which invested $550 million into Celsius in 2022 and became its primary U.S. distribution partner—significantly tightened its inventory orders. Because PepsiCo had over-ordered during the initial rollout, it pulled back to optimize its supply chain. Suddenly, Celsius's reported revenue growth fell off a cliff. Even though retail scanner data from Circana showed consumers were still buying cans at convenience stores and grocery chains, the gap between distributor orders and actual retail sell-through spooked institutional investors.

Cramer hates unpredictable inventory cycles, and he loves proven, cash-gushing compounders. When you put Celsius next to Monster Beverage Corporation, Cramer sees a sharp contrast. Monster has spent decades building an untouchable global distribution network through Coca-Cola, generating massive free cash flow, buying back billions in stock, and maintaining operating margins that make other consumer packaged goods companies jealous. To Cramer, betting on Celsius over Monster feels like paying a premium for an understudy when the star of the show is right there.

Monster Beverage vs Celsius Holdings on the Ground

Walk into any gas station in America, and you can immediately see what Celsius is up against. Cooler space is real estate, and in the beverage industry, real estate is war.

Monster doesn't just sell one green-clawed can anymore. They own a massive portfolio that hits every demographic. You have the flagship Monster Energy line, the wildly popular zero-sugar Monster Ultra line (which directly competes with Celsius's core demographic), Reign Total Body Fuel for the hardcore fitness crowd, and Bang Energy, which Monster scooped out of bankruptcy in 2023 for a fraction of its peak valuation.

Here is where Monster's scale crushes smaller competitors:

  • Global Footprint: Monster generates roughly 40% of its net sales outside the United States. Celsius is still overwhelmingly dependent on North America, though it has slowly begun pushing into the UK, Ireland, Australia, and France through Suntory and PepsiCo.
  • Pricing Power and Margins: Monster operates with gross margins consistently hovering above 53%. Because of its sheer volume and long-standing bottling agreements with Coca-Cola, Monster absorbs aluminum and freight inflation far better than smaller peers.
  • Shelf Dominance: Coca-Cola bottlers control the best eye-level cooler racks in convenience stores worldwide. Getting a new flavor of Monster Ultra into 100,000 stores takes weeks. For a smaller brand, fighting for every single shelf facing is a daily street fight.

Honestly, when you look at pure operational muscle, Cramer has a point. Monster is one of the greatest performing stocks in U.S. market history for a reason. From a strict business fundamentals perspective, Celsius is still playing catch-up.

Where Cramer's Take Misses the Mark

Calling Celsius "second rate" ignores a massive shift in consumer behavior that Monster was initially slow to catch.

Traditional energy drinks built their empires on extreme sports, gaming, and late-night shifts. Think dirt bikes, heavy metal, and massive 16-ounce cans. Celsius flipped the script entirely. They shrunk the can to 12 ounces, used clean white packaging with bright fruit imagery, and positioned the drink as a lifestyle accessory rather than an extreme stimulant.

If you walk into a Pilates studio, a corporate office, or a college lecture hall today, you won't see many people cracking open a classic black-and-green Monster. You'll see dozens of slim white Celsius cans sitting on desks.

Celsius didn't just steal market share from Monster and Red Bull; it expanded the entire energy drink category by bringing in people who previously only drank iced coffee or diet soda. Women make up roughly half of Celsius's consumer base—a demographic that historically avoided the energy drink aisle altogether.

Monster eventually recognized the threat and responded aggressively with its Monster Ultra flavors and Reign Storm, a direct 12-ounce competitor aimed straight at Celsius's core audience. You don't launch a copycat product line like Reign Storm if your competitor is truly "second rate." You launch it because you're worried about losing market share.

The PepsiCo Factor Blessing or Bottleneck

You can't analyze Celsius as an investment without looking closely at its relationship with PepsiCo. On paper, the 2022 deal was a dream come true. PepsiCo took an 8.5% ownership stake in Celsius and took over distribution across the United States, instantly unlocking access to independent convenience stores, foodservice accounts, and college campuses that Celsius could never reach on its own.

In practice, it created a single-customer concentration risk that Wall Street struggles to price.

PepsiCo accounts for roughly 60% of Celsius's total revenue. When PepsiCo's supply chain team decides to trim warehouse inventory by even a few days' worth of supply, Celsius's quarterly earnings take a direct hit. We saw this play out painfully when Celsius's stock dropped more than 60% from its 2024 highs, punishing anyone who bought at the peak of the hype cycle.

Meanwhile, PepsiCo owns Rockstar Energy, which it bought for $3.85 billion in 2020. While Celsius has vastly outperformed Rockstar in retail growth, PepsiCo's own priorities don't always align perfectly with Celsius's shareholders. If PepsiCo's bottling trucks are focused on pushing Gatorade, Mountain Dew, or their own energy initiatives during peak summer months, Celsius can sometimes feel like a passenger rather than the driver.

Compare that to Monster's partnership with Coca-Cola. Coca-Cola owns roughly 19% of Monster and uses Monster as its exclusive global energy vehicle. There is zero brand conflict inside the Coke system. Every Coke bottler on earth is incentivized to push Monster to the front of the cooler. That structural alignment is a massive advantage that Celsius still hasn't fully replicated.

The Valuation Trap and Growth Reality

A few years ago, Celsius traded at nosebleed valuations—often above 70 or 80 times forward earnings. Investors were pricing in perfection, assuming 50% annual revenue growth would continue indefinitely.

Markets eventually punish that kind of optimism. As U.S. energy drink category growth slowed down from double digits to mid-single digits due to broader inflation squeezing convenience store shoppers, Celsius's valuation compressed violently.

At the same time, the energy drink aisle got dangerously crowded. Look at what happened over the last few years:

  • Alani Nu surged in popularity among younger female consumers with aggressive influencer marketing and dessert-inspired flavors.
  • Ghost Energy exploded onto the scene with authentic candy collaborations like Sour Patch Kids and Swedish Fish, eventually catching the eye of Keurig Dr Pepper, which announced a massive $990 million deal to acquire Ghost in late 2024.
  • C4 Energy (Nutrabolt) leveraged a huge distribution deal with Keurig Dr Pepper to grab serious market share in convenience stores.
  • Prime Energy and Red Bull's constant seasonal flavor drops continued fighting for the exact same impulse buyers at the gas station register.

When competition intensifies like this, marketing costs go up. Celsius has had to spend significantly more on slotting fees, promotional discounts, and advertising just to defend its 11% to 12% share of the U.S. energy drink market. Higher marketing spend means tighter operating margins, which gives value-oriented commentators like Jim Cramer plenty of ammunition to favor Monster's fortress balance sheet.

How to Decide Between CELH and MNST

If you're looking at your portfolio and trying to figure out whether to listen to Cramer or buy the dip on Celsius, stop looking at the stock tickers for a minute and look at what kind of investor you actually are. They represent two completely different risk profiles.

Monster Beverage (MNST) makes sense if you want:

  • Predictable, steady mid-to-high single-digit revenue growth backed by global expansion in emerging markets like Latin America and Asia.
  • Fortress-level financials with virtually no debt, massive free cash flow, and consistent share buybacks that put a floor under the stock price.
  • Lower volatility. You won't wake up to a 20% drop just because a distributor tweaked its warehouse software.

Celsius Holdings (CELH) makes sense if you want:

  • Higher upside potential from international expansion. If Celsius can replicate even a fraction of its U.S. success in Europe and Asia-Pacific over the next five years, today's revenue numbers will look small.
  • A pure-play bet on the "better-for-you" health and wellness trend continuing to eat away at traditional sugary sodas and legacy energy drinks.
  • Higher risk tolerance. You have to be comfortable stomach-churning swings whenever quarterly retail scanner data fluctuates or PepsiCo adjusts inventory levels.

Practical Next Steps Before You Buy Either Stock

Don't blindly follow a 10-second lightning round soundbite—even from someone as experienced as Jim Cramer—and don't blindly buy a beaten-down growth stock just because it looks cheaper than it did last year. Do your own legwork first.

Start by tracking the weekly or monthly Circana (formerly IRI) retail scanner data shared by beverage analysts on financial news sites. Ignore the noise around wholesale shipments for a moment and look strictly at retail dollar sales and unit volume growth at convenience stores. That tells you whether real people are still pulling cans off the shelf.

Next, pull up the latest quarterly earnings transcripts for both Celsius and Monster. Look specifically at gross margins and international revenue percentages. For Celsius, you want to see gross margins holding steady around 50% despite promotional spending, and you want to see international sales growing faster than North American sales. For Monster, watch how well their zero-sugar Monster Ultra line is defending its turf against upstarts.

Finally, check your position sizing. If you decide Celsius has enough brand loyalty to prove Cramer wrong over the long haul, treat it like a volatile mid-cap growth stock rather than a safe consumer staple. Scale in slowly instead of going all-in at once, and keep an eye on the cooler doors next time you stop for gas—sometimes the best market research is right in front of you.

NB

Nathan Barnes

Nathan Barnes is known for uncovering stories others miss, combining investigative skills with a knack for accessible, compelling writing.