Bill Shaikin wants you to relax about the Los Angeles Dodgers not having a designated playoff closer. The mainstream consensus chimes right in with him, arguing that flexibility is king, that modern bullpens are modular, and that locking yourself into a traditional ninth-inning stopper is an outdated relic of the 1990s.
They are wrong. Not because a traditional closer is a sacred baseball institution, but because worshipping at the altar of high-leverage fluidity has created a panic-driven, over-managed mess. You might also find this connected article useful: The Economics of Inaction Capital Allocation and the RJ Barrett Dilemma.
When you refuse to name a closer under the guise of tactical optionality, you aren't being modern. You are broadcasting anxiety. You are telling every arm in that bullpen that nobody has earned the manager's trust when the lights burn hottest.
Let us dismantle the lazy consensus piece by piece. As reported in recent coverage by Yahoo Sports, the results are significant.
The Illusion of Modular Bullpen Engineering
The entire argument against a designated closer rests on a fundamental misunderstanding of human psychology under extreme stress. Front offices love to treat relievers like chess pieces on a spreadsheet. In theory, if the seventh inning carries the highest win-probability-added index against the heart of the order, your best arm should pitch right there.
Here is what the spreadsheet misses: human beings require role clarity to execute at peak performance.
When a relief pitcher knows his job is to get the final three outs of a tight ballgame, his entire mental preparation narrows. He visualizes the specific hitters he will face. He hones his warmup routine for the exact moment the eighth inning transitions to the ninth. Strip away that definition, and you get a clubhouse full of guys guessing when the phone is going to ring, burning nervous energy in the dugout, and over-thinking their mechanics because every single appearance is treated like a crisis management scenario.
I have spoken with veteran relievers who spent decades navigating these high-stakes environments, and the consensus behind closed doors is unanimous. Constant role shifting breeds hesitation. Hesitation in October means a fastball left over the plate to a slugger who feasts on uncertainty.
Why High-Leverage Flexibility Backfires
The anti-closer crowd loves to point to instances where deploying an elite arm in the seventh inning neutralized a threat and saved the game. Sure. It works on paper until it backfires in practice.
Imagine a scenario where a manager burns his hardest-throwing shutdown arm in the seventh inning to put out a fire, only to watch the bottom of the ninth unravel because the remaining options are middle-tier setup men who are now pitching out of position in a role they rarely occupy. You didn't solve the leverage problem; you simply relocated the panic from the seventh inning to the ninth.
The Dodgers have the financial muscle to buy every elite arm on the open market, but buying arms is not the same as building an architecture of trust. When October baseball reaches its boiling point, hitters are hunting specific velocities and movement profiles. If a closer enters the game with a clear mandate, the psychological weight shifts entirely to the batter. The hitter knows the closer only throws one pitch sequence. The contest becomes a pure execution battle.
Remove that structure, and the pitcher starts nibbling. He tries to manage outcomes instead of dominating the strike zone.
The Cost of Over-Management
Baseball has fallen victim to the tyranny of the optimal math nerd. Every single decision must be justified by a projected win-probability metric.
The human element—rhythm, momentum, posture, and plain old-fashioned swagger—gets discarded because it cannot be neatly formatted into a CSV file. A designated closer provides a psychological anchor for the entire dugout. When the starter leaves with a lead, everyone from the bench coach to the batboy looks down the bullpen and knows exactly who is slamming the door.
Without that anchor, the dugout spends the seventh and eighth innings holding its collective breath, wondering which tactical puzzle piece the manager is going to pull out next. That subtle shift in team posture matters. Confidence is contagious, but so is hesitation.
Stop Trying to Fix the Ninth Inning
The desire to reinvent the ninth inning is a solution in search of a problem. A designated closer is not a failure of imagination; it is an acknowledgment that certain moments require a specialized assassin.
If your bullpen lacks a definitive ninth-inning option, do not romanticize it as cutting-edge roster construction. Call it what it is: a structural vulnerability disguised as sophistication. The Dodgers can win a World Series in spite of this philosophy, but they will do it by sheer force of talent, not because their bullpen management style is a blueprint for the future.
Hand the ball to one guy. Let him own the ninth. Stop overthinking it.